Skip to content
ISSN NO. : 0970-4175 (Print)

 

Search

The Book ReviewThe Book Review
The Book Review
  • HOME
  • THE BOOK REVIEW
    • ABOUT
    • FOUNDER TRUSTEES
    • THE JOURNAL
  • SUBSCRIPTIONS
    • PRINT & DIGITAL EDITION
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • ARCHIVES
    • Table of Contents
    • Reviews
  • MEDIA & EVENTS
    • EVENTS
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • HOME
  • THE BOOK REVIEW
    • ABOUT
    • FOUNDER TRUSTEES
    • THE JOURNAL
  • SUBSCRIPTIONS
    • PRINT & DIGITAL EDITION
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • ARCHIVES
    • Table of Contents
    • Reviews
  • MEDIA & EVENTS
    • EVENTS
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISEMENT

Post-Partition State-making in South Asia

Review Details

Book Name: ANIMOSITY AT BAY: AN ALTERNATIVE HISTORY OF THE INDIA-PAKISTAN RELATIONSHIP, 1947-1952
Author name: Pallavi Raghavan
Book Year: 2020
Book Price: 699.00
Reviewer name: Shivshankar Menon
Volume No: 44
Publisher Name: HarperCollins, India
Book Pages: 247

Pallavi Raghavan has written a remarkable book on the early years of India-Pakistan relations. This is history as it should be written—granular, rigorous, following the evidence, and not afraid to ask big questions. Based on detailed archival work, she presents a fresh view of how India and Pakistan worked together in several foundational aspects as they began state and nation building just after Partition.

Raghavan looks at some of the most sensitive issues in the aftermath of Partition such as the treatment of minorities, evacuee property, exchanges on a No War Pact, Indus Waters, their international personalities, and trade and financial relations. In each case she shows how, despite disagreements which were obviously present, both India and Pakistan were embarked on a process of state-making that had to be mutually constituted. She argues that at its heart, the India-Pakistan relationship contains a collaborative element in that it assumes a mutual acknowledgement of the validity of both states. In the early days of the new states, both countries were aware of the intense fragility of the nation-state project in South Asia. Both therefore needed to collaborate as part of willing the postcolonial states into existence. Both worked to make the process of separation as complete as possible, disentangling the multiple ties of kinship, language, familial relations and religion that held their people together.

Raghavan examines how the two new states cooperated and engaged with each other in the years following Partition, impelled by the imperative to acknowledge the validity of the state structures of both India and Pakistan. She goes so far as to call them mutually constituted entities and says that ‘their contours are held in place by one another’. Their cooperation, negotiations and decisions on war and peace were ‘the product of a joint agenda of recognizing the finality of partition’.

Please Login or Register to Read Entire Article !

Username:
Password:
Register
Lost your password?

Post navigation

PreviousPrevious post:Questioning Paradigms and StereotypesNextNext post:The Story of Transnational Islam

Related posts

Questioning Paradigms and Stereotypes
June 25, 2020
Post-Partition State-making in South Asia
June 14, 2020
The Story of Transnational Islam
June 14, 2020
A Portrait of Rich Friendships
June 15, 2020
From Political Freedom to a Socialist Revolution
June 15, 2020
A Spectacular Art Heritage
June 15, 2020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

clear formPost comment

Current Issue
  • Issue 2002 November January 12, 2021
  • Issue 2002 September January 12, 2021
Search in website

ABOUT US | DISCLAIMER | ADVERTISEMENT

All Right Reserved with The Book Review Literacy Trust | Powered by Digital Empowerment Foundation

FacebookTwitter