Mapping the Indian States
Satish C Aikant
WE THE PEOPLE OF THE STATES OF BHARAT: THE MAKING AND REMAKING OF INDIA’S INTERNAL BOUNDARIES by Sanjeev Chopra HarperCollins, Gurugram, 2022, 397 pp., 799.00
June 2023, volume 47, No 6

The territory no longer precedes the map, nor survives it. Henceforth, it is the map that precedes the territory.

– Jean Baudrillard (1983)

In a  crucial scene set in an underground temple  in Bankimchandra Chatterji’s Anandamath, the protagonist Mahendra first encounters the Motherland, as he goes into a dark room, and ‘Gradually a picture revealed itself to him. It was a gigantic, imposing, resplendent, yes, almost a living map of India. This is our Mother India as she was before British conquest,’ he was told. Then, Mahendra goes into the next room where he sees ‘a map of India in rags and tears. The gloom over this map was beyond description. This is what our Mother India is today,’ he was informed.

A modern nation state can only be imagined in the mapped form. If it were not for the map, conception of a nation state would remain an abstraction, leaving its inhabitants without any material means to relate to the country to which they would feel attached.  Maps serve as markers of presence. A map enables the citizen-subject to take visual and conceptual possession of the nation-space that he inhabits. In fact, map making is an essential tool of the technology of persuasion. The territories/spaces, of course, can also be considered as shifting grounds which are themselves transformational patterns of de- and re-territorialization. Maps are texts that  describe and redescribe the world, like any other document, in terms of relations of power and of cultural practices, preferences, and priorities.

Continue reading this review