When I first picked up The Rose Bargain, I found myself debating how best to classify it. Was it romance, fantasy, or historical fiction? The answer lies in the increasingly popular term Romantasy—a seamless blend of romance and fantasy. This duology marks my first encounter with Sasha Peyton Smith’s writing, and she certainly has a way with words and a natural flow to her storytelling.
The novel is set in 1848 England, but this is no ordinary historical backdrop, ruled not by a monarch of flesh and blood but by an immortal faerie queen. This queen bargains with mortals, granting wishes in exchange for something of great personal value—often life-altering and sometimes devastating. At the centre of this world is Ivy Benton, a young debutante stepping into society. Much of the narrative revolves around the competition among young women to win the hand of the Prince, a setup that blends courtly intrigue with faerie magic. This is a concept that immediately sparks curiosity, promising a mix of historical setting, fantastical elements, and romantic tension.
The concept is intriguing, but much of the plot unfolds predictably. Rather than building suspense or deepening the intrigue, the constant shifts sometimes make the story feel scattered, as though the threads don’t quite weave together into a cohesive whole. The relationships—whether romantic, familial, or friendly—often come across as superficial. It seems clear that the author intended to portray them as layered and meaningful, but for me, they lacked the emotional depth needed to truly resonate. This disconnect made it harder to invest in the characters’ journeys.
That said, the book does have moments where it shines. Toward the end of several chapters, the narrative regains momentum, adding intrigue and leaving you curious about what comes next. It is one of those stories where, even if you suspect where it is heading, you still feel compelled to see it through and look forward to reading the sequel.
For me, The Rose Bargain was a fun, light read—something you pick up knowing it won’t necessarily surprise you, but will still entertain. It didn’t quite live up to the hype I had encountered before reading, but it wasn’t without merit. The writing style is accessible, the pacing ensures you’re never bored, and the blend of romance and fantasy makes it appealing to fans of the genre. If you enjoy stories that mix the elegance of Bridgerton, the competitive drama of The Selection, and the faerie intrigue of The Cruel Prince, then this book will likely be a satisfying addition to your shelf.