Skip to content
ISSN NO. : 0970-4175 (Print)

 

Search

The Book Review, Monthly Review of Important BooksThe Book Review, Monthly Review of Important Books
The Book Review, Monthly Review of Important Books
  • HOME
  • THE BOOK REVIEW
    • ABOUT
    • FOUNDER TRUSTEES
    • THE JOURNAL
  • SUBSCRIPTIONS
    • PRINT & DIGITAL EDITION
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • ARCHIVES
    • Table of Contents
    • Reviews
  • MEDIA & EVENTS
    • EVENTS
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • HOME
  • THE BOOK REVIEW
    • ABOUT
    • FOUNDER TRUSTEES
    • THE JOURNAL
  • SUBSCRIPTIONS
    • PRINT & DIGITAL EDITION
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • ARCHIVES
    • Table of Contents
    • Reviews
  • MEDIA & EVENTS
    • EVENTS
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISEMENT

Autobiographical Reflections

Review Details

Book Name: WHY I AM NOT A HINDU WOMAN: A PERSONAL STORY
Author name: Wandana Sonalkar
Book Year: 2021
Book Price: 350.00
Reviewer name: Preeti Gulati
Volume No: 45
Publisher Name: Women Unlimited Press, Delhi
Book Pages: 169

Why I am not a Hindu Woman is Wandana Sonalkar’s autobiographical reflections on Hinduism as a religion, as an upper-caste Marxist feminist, and in the context of India’s socio-political journey in the last seventy three years, particularly in the shadow of Hindutva majoritarian politics. Sonalkar uses her life and experiences as an entry point to the wider social and political climate of the time, moving fluidly from normative texts composed c. 300 CE to India’s early years as an independent republic, while also bringing into the narrative recent public movements from Bhima-Koregaon to the pan-India anti-CAA/NRC protests. Across this vast time span, Sonalkar makes a compelling case for rupturing the private and political divide, by tracing the roots of the political philosophy of Hindutva in the Hindu normative ideals of family and household.

Historiographically, Sonalkar locates herself amid a series of books written mostly by men on their own relationship. Notably, these include Kancha Ilaiah’s path-breaking Dalit Bahujan Critique of Hinduism (1996), Shashi Tharoor’s attempt at reclaiming a more pluralistic, tolerant Hinduism (2018), the Marathi film director Atul Pethe’s similar attempts at showing how his Hinduism is not violent (September 2018), Bertrand Russell’s (1927) and Ibn Farraq’s (1995) monumental pieces on their disassociation with Christianity and Islam respectively. The exception in Sonalkar’s outline of her field is Ruth Vanita’s critique of the Left in India (2002), which, by disassociating from Hinduism, also failed to mount a critique of casteism, both in idea and practice (p.18). Against these, Wandana Sonalkar sets herself apart by writing from the point of experience as a woman in a Hindu family. Why I am not a Hindu Woman is thus a feminist critique of the inequalities inherent in ‘“every day, lived Hinduism’ (p. 24).

Sonalkar lays out this feminist critique by tying together practices in her upper-caste household, her initial education in Singapore and Cambridge, the strong anti-caste Ambedkarite discourse in Maharashtra, and the Hindutva politics in India. Through five chapters, Sonalkar makes two broad arguments: first, that what she identifies as Brahmanical Hinduism has an inherent penchant for violence, particularly against women and Dalits; and second that Hindutva is sustained on two simultaneous processes of otherization of the ‘internal inferiors’ (Dalits and women) and the ‘external enemies’ (Muslims). Unlike Tharoor or Pethe’s attempts at ‘rescuing’ Hinduism from Hindutva, Sonalkar argues that there are inherent inequalities in Hinduism along caste and gender lines, which in turn form the foundation of and fuel the violence of Hindutva, and herein lies her rejection of her identity as a Hindu woman.

Please Login or Register to Read Entire Article !

Username:
Password:
Register
Lost your password?

Post navigation

PreviousPrevious post:A No-Holds Barred MemoirNextNext post:A Saga of Love, Endurance and Survival

Related posts

An Indian in the Land of Yuan Zang
February 4, 2021
A No-Holds Barred Memoir
February 4, 2021
Autobiographical Reflections
February 5, 2021
A Saga of Love, Endurance and Survival
February 5, 2021
A Biographical Overview
February 5, 2021
Tracing Patterns through Various Planes of Interrogation
February 5, 2021

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

clear formPost comment

Current Issue
  • The Real and the Immersive March 5, 2021
  • Vulnerable Others in and of Environmental Research March 5, 2021
Search in website

ABOUT US | DISCLAIMER | ADVERTISEMENT

All Right Reserved with The Book Review Literacy Trust | Powered by Digital Empowerment Foundation

FacebookTwitter